Great Vintage Port Tasting
Vintage 1963
Our wine club ‘The Wine Society 18%’ celebrates its 20 th anniversary this year and we have during these 20 years tasted quite a lot of vintage port. It has been altogether 556 different vintage ports ranging from 1873 to 1999. Of course we have tasted a lot from the 21st century too, but they are so young. Unfortunately we have only tasted 3 vintage ports from the 19th century. We are 15 members and have 5 meetings/year and then some extra now and then. We are only 15 members so we can have quite rare bottles i.e. 1 bottle is enough. The meetings are in Malmö, Sweden. We had planned to have some tastings due to this celebration and started already the year before (i.e. 2012) as we planned our club the year 1992. The first of the celebration tastings was the vintage 1978 and after that we had celebration tastings of the vintages 1979 and 1947 as extra tastings this year and we have ended the celebration year with a Great Tasting of 1963 which included 38 houses.
The Wine Society 18% has had once a year a Great Tasting since 2005 and we started this Great Tasting with 39 houses of the vintage 1963 and after that we have had Great Tasting of the following vintages: 1960, 1966, 1970, 1975 and 1977 before our Celebration Year which included 4 Great Tastings. Unfortunately 4 of the houses from the tasting 8 years ago were missing this time but we had 3 new houses that we did not have last time.
We were 17 participants in the tasting. The tasting was semi-blind i.e. we know which houses participate in each Flight but not what we had in each glass. We had 4 Flights and in the last Flight we had, as we also had in 2005, an extra vintage Port i.e. Quinta de Noval Nacional 1962 and the same happened this tasting too, 1962 Nacional was split best in show!
The 1963 vintage is a classic Vintage, intense and perfect balanced, deep-purple, fruity and with a large aging capacity. Almost all shippers declared. According to Broadbent 25 shippers declared and according to Port Wine Institute, IVDP, 44 shippers declared. Broadbent and Decanter gave this vintage ***** out of 5*, Suckling 98 points out of 100 and IVDP 7 out of 7. We rated it as Classic and gave it 10 out of 10.
The tasting was conducted over four flights.
First flight:
Second flight:
Third flight:
Fourth flight:
Tasting notes. Note that the points are for the actual bottle tasted. Read about how we set point on the page "How to understand our points valuations"
Sort on: Name Sten's rank Jörgen's rank Stefan's rank Group's rank
House | Andresen | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Quite beautiful in colour, almost tawny. |
Bouquet | Burned candy, brown sugar and some pharmacy in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and even some tired. Burned candy in taste. Still quite elegant and balanced with a nice finish. |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 14.90 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 14.57 |
SAI rank | 32 | JB rank | 37 | SS rank | 24 | Group rank | 36 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Barros | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Dark, yellow mature beautiful in colour. |
Bouquet | Complex wonderful nose of old grocery shop, cacao, crème caramel, coffee and much more. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and at its peak but still some soft tannin. Cacao and toffee in taste. Elegant and balanced port with lots of complexity. Wonderful! |
SAI point | 17.75 | JB point | 17.75 | SS point | 17.50 | Group point | 16.97 |
SAI rank | 5 | JB rank | 7 | SS rank | 11 | Group rank | 10 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Borges & Irmao | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful yellow, mature in colour but rather dark. |
Bouquet | Lovely, complex bouquet. Mostly old grocery shop, figs and cinnamon but also some pharmacy. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and maybe even a little old. Cinnamon in taste. Complex port with an elegant finish. |
SAI point | 16.40 | JB point | 15.90 | SS point | 16.50 | Group point | 14.94 |
SAI rank | 25 | JB rank | 27 | SS rank | 18 | Group rank | 32 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Burmester | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Elegant, complex bouquet of truffles, dark berry, mulberry and mint in the nose. Very impressive. |
Taste | Quite full-bodied. Wonderful complex taste. Flavour of dark chocolate and cacao. Mature and at its peak Delicious and quite long finish. |
SAI point | 16.00 | JB point | 15.75 | SS point | 15.40 | Group point | 15.29 |
SAI rank | 27 | JB rank | 29 | SS rank | 29 | Group rank | 27 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Calem | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature but still rather dark in colour. |
Bouquet | Wonderful complex old grocery shop, cinnamon, coffee, burned sugar and toffee bouquet. |
Taste | Full bodied. Very tasty indeed. Mature and at its peak. Plum in taste. Complex, very sweet, balanced and elegant with an enormous finish. Wonderful port! |
SAI point | 16.90 | JB point | 16.90 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 16.44 |
SAI rank | 11 | JB rank | 13 | SS rank | 24 | Group rank | 16 |
Comment | The Group had a split ranking SS: Something disturbing in the nose, not really ok for me. |
House | Cockburn | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Attractive mature and yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Wonderful complex bouquet of old grocery shop, coffee, fudge, toffee, tea, cacao and much more. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. Vanilla, toffee, fudge and chocolate in taste. Dry but balanced. Long finish. Easy to drink and an attractive port. One of our favourites. |
SAI point | 16.50 | JB point | 16.40 | SS point | 17.00 | Group point | 16.38 |
SAI rank | 22 | JB rank | 20 | SS rank | 13 | Group rank | 18 |
Comment | SS had a split ranking. |
House | Croft | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow almost tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Fudge, toffee, ginger and old grocery shop in the nose. |
Taste | Quite full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. Toffee in taste. Fairly sweet, elegant and balanced with a delicious and quite long finish. |
SAI point | 16.40 | JB point | 16.40 | SS point | 15.75 | Group point | 16.03 |
SAI rank | 25 | JB rank | 20 | SS rank | 23 | Group rank | 21 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Delaforce | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature almost tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Quite closed in the nose with figs, pharmacy and hospital. |
Taste | Medium body. Full mature and maybe a little old but very elegant with some pharmacy in taste. A nice but maybe a little short finish. |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 15.40 | SS point | 15.00 | Group point | 15.09 |
SAI rank | 32 | JB rank | 33 | SS rank | 33 | Group rank | 29 |
Comment | SAI had a split ranking |
House | Diez Hermanos | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | A bit closed in the nose with pharmacy. Ginger bread and burned sugar bouquet. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and maybe a little old now. Dried fruit and fudge in taste. Delicious and balanced with a nice finish. |
SAI point | 15.40 | JB point | 15.50 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 14.97 |
SAI rank | 35 | JB rank | 31 | SS rank | 24 | Group rank | 31 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Dow | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature almost tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Complex nose of roses, candy and ginger and spiciness in the nose. |
Taste | Full-bodied with almond paste and ginger in flavour. Mature and peaking. Elegant and balanced with a long and attractive finish. |
SAI point | 17.00 | JB point | 17.75 | SS point | 18.00 | Group point | 17.64 |
SAI rank | 10 | JB rank | 7 | SS rank | 7 | Group rank | 5 |
Comment | JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Feist | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Complex pharmacy, Sultan raisin nuts and ginger bread in the nose. |
Taste | Lovely body. Medium body. Mature, peaking and even a little old. Ginger bread and nuts in taste. Attractive And balance finish. |
SAI point | 15.40 | JB point | 15.50 | SS point | 15.25 | Group point | 14.29 |
SAI rank | 35 | JB rank | 31 | SS rank | 30 | Group rank | 38 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Feuerheerd | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow colour. |
Bouquet | Cacao, dark chocolate and coffee in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and maybe a little old. Elegant with cacao in taste. Complex port with a quite attractive finish. |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 15.00 | SS point | 14.75 | Group point | 14.00 |
SAI rank | 32 | JB rank | 34 | SS rank | 35 | Group rank | 39 |
Comment | |
House | Fonseca | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful, yellow and mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Enormous bouquet of crème caramel, violet and liquorice. |
Taste | Full-bodied, still some soft tannins. Complex and balanced port with violet in taste and an extremely long finish. Wonderful port. |
SAI point | 19.00 | JB point | 19.50 | SS point | 16.50 | Group point | 16.79 |
SAI rank | 4 | JB rank | 3 | SS rank | 18 | Group rank | 13 |
Comment | JB and SS had a split ranking SS: This wine was corked for me. Even so it was quite impressive. |
House | Gonzalez-Byass | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature tawny colour. |
Bouquet | Ginger bread, figs and pharmacy in the nose. |
Taste | Hardly medium body. Mature and maybe a little old. Pharmacy in taste. Still knit together and balanced but a short finish. |
SAI point | 14.00 | JB point | 14.50 | SS point | 14.50 | Group point | 14.47 |
SAI rank | 38 | JB rank | 38 | SS rank | 38 | Group rank | 37 |
Comment | |
House | Graham | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Dark yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Chocolate, coffee, violet and old grocery shop in the nose. A wonderful bouquet. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and on top. Cacao and toffee in taste. Elegant and balanced with a complex and never ending finish. Lovely port which continue developing in the glass. Astonishing! We just love this port! |
SAI point | 19.50 | JB point | 20.00 | SS point | 20.00 | Group point | 18.14 |
SAI rank | 3 | JB rank | 1 | SS rank | 1 | Group rank | 3 |
Comment | JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Hooper | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Nice mature quite dark in colour. |
Bouquet | Crème caramel, nuts Christmas raisin and some pharmacy in the nose. Quite elegant. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and at its peak. Sweet. Nuts and cacao in taste. A complex and lovely finish. Lovely port! |
SAI point | 17.75 | JB point | 16.90 | SS point | 16.90 | Group point | 16.46 |
SAI rank | 5 | JB rank | 13 | SS rank | 16 | Group rank | 15 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Hunt | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | A bit old in the nose. Dark chocolate, nuts and pharmacy. |
Taste | Medium body. Burned sugar and nuts in flavour. Mature and quite long and elegant finish. |
SAI point | 15.75 | JB point | 15.00 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 14.89 |
SAI rank | 29 | JB rank | 34 | SS rank | 24 | Group rank | 33 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Kopke | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow very beautiful in colour. |
Bouquet | Fudge, burned candy hospital and ginger bread in the nose. |
Taste | Rather full bodied. Mature and peaking. Toffee in taste. Complex with a lovely, long and very attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.75 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 16.75 | Group point | 15.35 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 23 | SS rank | 17 | Group rank | 26 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Mackenzie | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature lovely colour. |
Bouquet | Full complex nose of coffee, crème caramel, ginger bread and toffee. |
Taste | Excellent body. Complex and balance port. Mature and peaking. Toffee in taste. Attractive port with a long finish. |
SAI point | 16.75 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 16.40 | Group point | 14.88 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 23 | SS rank | 21 | Group rank | 34 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Martinez | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Lovely complex old grocery shop, crème caramel, naphthalene, pharmacy and burned sugar in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Sweet. Mature and maybe peaking but perhaps faded a little. However, elegant and a wonderful finish. Quite delicious. |
SAI point | 16.75 | JB point | 16.50 | SS point | 17.00 | Group point | 16.38 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 16 | SS rank | 13 | Group rank | 18 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Messias | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Light coloured tawny with an olive green rim. |
Bouquet | Sweet burned candy, fudge and pharmacy in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Seemed a bit old and had some alcoholic taste, but easy to drink and in a way knit together anyhow. Nice finish. |
SAI point | 14.90 | JB point | 15.00 | SS point | 14.75 | Group point | 15.04 |
SAI rank | 37 | JB rank | 34 | SS rank | 35 | Group rank | 30 |
Comment | JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Niepoort | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow colour. |
Bouquet | Crème caramel, cacao, dark chocolate and toffee. Complex and elegant nose. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. Taste of crème caramel and viol. Elegant and balanced with a complex long and wonderful finish. Marvellous port! |
SAI point | 20.00 | JB point | 19.50 | SS point | 18.40 | Group point | 18.07 |
SAI rank | 1 | JB rank | 3 | SS rank | 5 | Group rank | 4 |
Comment | |
House | Offley Boa Vista | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful mature yellow colour but still rather dark. |
Bouquet | Lovely minty, pharmacy, fudge and old grocery shop in the nose. |
Taste | Quite full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. Minty in flavour. Elegant and balanced with a very long and lovely finish. |
SAI point | 16.50 | JB point | 16.50 | SS point | 15.25 | Group point | 16.04 |
SAI rank | 22 | JB rank | 16 | SS rank | 30 | Group rank | 20 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking SS: Hints of cork-defect for me. |
House | Pocas Jr | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Ginger bread, toffee and fudge in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and at its peak. Balanced and elegant. Crème caramel in taste with a wonderful and generous finish. Very good indeed. |
SAI point | 16.90 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 14.90 | Group point | 14.74 |
SAI rank | 11 | JB rank | 23 | SS rank | 34 | Group rank | 35 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Quarles Harris | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Still quite dark with yellow mature colour. |
Bouquet | Coffee, tea, crème caramel, and old grocery shop in the nose. |
Taste | Quite full-bodied. Mature and peaking but maybe a little old. Balanced and complex with a long, long finish. Still a lovely port. |
SAI point | 17.50 | JB point | 16.90 | SS point | 17.90 | Group point | 16.91 |
SAI rank | 8 | JB rank | 13 | SS rank | 9 | Group rank | 11 |
Comment | JB had a split ranking |
House | Quinta do Corval Real Comp. Velha | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Spring flowers and spiciness in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Very mature indeed very tasty. Balanced and quite elegant with a rather long finish. |
SAI point | 15.75 | JB point | 15.75 | SS point | 14.75 | Group point | 15.64 |
SAI rank | 29 | JB rank | 29 | SS rank | 35 | Group rank | 25 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Quinta do Noval | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Generous bouquet of crème caramel, toffee, fudge, burned candy in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Sweet and generous. Fudge and toffee in taste. Mature and peaking. Balanced and with a complex and lovely finish. It has really improved and been quite better during the last decade. |
SAI point | 16.90 | JB point | 18.00 | SS point | 18.00 | Group point | 17.07 |
SAI rank | 11 | JB rank | 5 | SS rank | 7 | Group rank | 9 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Quinta do Noval Nacional | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful, still quite dark but yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Dark berry, tobacco, violet coffee, cacao and much more in the nose. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Still fruit and tannins but wonderfully balanced. Rather mature but will develop more. Balanced and complex. Marvellous finish. Can port be better? |
SAI point | 19.90 | JB point | 20.00 | SS point | 20.00 | Group point | 18.75 |
SAI rank | 2 | JB rank | 1 | SS rank | 1 | Group rank | 2 |
Comment | JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Quinta do Sibio Real Vinicola | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Beautiful mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Generous bouquet of cacao, dark chocolate, coffee, old grocery shop and cinnamon in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and at its peak. Cacao and chocolate in taste. Sweet. Elegant and balanced port with a long, lovely and attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.75 | JB point | 15.90 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 15.25 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 27 | SS rank | 24 | Group rank | 28 |
Comment | SAI and SS had a split ranking |
House | Quinta do Vesuvio Ferreira | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow quite nice colour. |
Bouquet | Complex mint, toffee, burned candy and crème caramel in the nose. |
Taste | Mature and at its peak. Quite full-bodied. Toffee in flavour. Elegant and balanced. Complex, long and quite attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.90 | JB point | 16.50 | SS point | 17.00 | Group point | 15.82 |
SAI rank | 11 | JB rank | 16 | SS rank | 13 | Group rank | 23 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Ramos Pinto | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Old grocery shop, pharmacy and burned sugar in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and maybe a little old with some acidity. Complex port with a lovely and quite attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.00 | JB point | 16.50 | SS point | 16.00 | Group point | 16.44 |
SAI rank | 27 | JB rank | 16 | SS rank | 22 | Group rank | 16 |
Comment | SAI and JB as well as the Group had a split ranking |
House | Real Vinicola | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature almost tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Pepper, cacao, nuts and crème caramel in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and maybe a little old. Nuts and toffee in flavour. Elegant and quite balanced with an attractive finish. |
SAI point | 15.75 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 16.50 | Group point | 16.00 |
SAI rank | 29 | JB rank | 23 | SS rank | 18 | Group rank | 22 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Rebello Valente Robertson | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Crème caramel, herbal, pharmacy, raisin and cinnamon in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and at its peak. Toffee and herbal in flavour and a lovely and complex finish. Delicious port indeed. |
SAI point | 16.75 | JB point | 17.40 | SS point | 17.25 | Group point | 16.74 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 12 | SS rank | 12 | Group rank | 14 |
Comment | SAI had a split ranking |
House | Sandeman | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Still dark but mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Very complex nose of coffee, cacao, tea, ginger, cinnamon and much more. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and on top. Mostly fudge and toffee in taste but very tasty. Balanced and complex port with a generous, lovely and attractive finish. How wonderful!! |
SAI point | 17.75 | JB point | 17.50 | SS point | 18.25 | Group point | 17.57 |
SAI rank | 5 | JB rank | 10 | SS rank | 6 | Group rank | 6 |
Comment | SAI, JB and SS had a split ranking |
House | Smith-Woodhouse | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Lovely burned sugar, coffee, toffee and cacao in the nose. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and on top. Sweet. Toffee and pharmacy in taste. Complex and wonderful port with a lovely and very very long finish. |
SAI point | 17.50 | JB point | 17.75 | SS point | 17.75 | Group point | 16.79 |
SAI rank | 8 | JB rank | 7 | SS rank | 10 | Group rank | 12 |
Comment | |
House | Taylor | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Violets, coffee, tea, cacao and ginger in the nose. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. More of burned candy in taste. Balanced and complex port with an enormous and attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.90 | JB point | 17.50 | SS point | 18.50 | Group point | 17.25 |
SAI rank | 11 | JB rank | 10 | SS rank | 4 | Group rank | 8 |
Comment | SAI and JB had a split ranking |
House | Warre | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow almost tawny in colour. |
Bouquet | Lovely nose of coffee, tea, toffee, cacao and ginger. |
Taste | Full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. Very tasty with coffee and cacao in flavour. Complex and balanced. Sweet. A wonderful, long and incredible finish. |
SAI point | 16.90 | JB point | 18.00 | SS point | 18.75 | Group point | 17.43 |
SAI rank | 11 | JB rank | 5 | SS rank | 3 | Group rank | 7 |
Comment | JB had a split ranking |
House | Wiese-Krohn | Vintage | 1963 |
Colour | Mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Crème caramel burned sugar, coffee, Sultan raisin and bitter chocolate in the nose. |
Taste | Quite full-bodied. Mature and at its peak. Elegant, balanced and complex port with a long and quite attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.50 | JB point | 16.25 | SS point | 15.25 | Group point | 15.79 |
SAI rank | 22 | JB rank | 22 | SS rank | 30 | Group rank | 24 |
Comment | SAI and SS had a split ranking |