Great Vintage Port Tasting
Vintage 1989
On November 21, 2019, we arranged a tasting of 27 different Vintage Ports from 1989. We were 16 attending participants in the tasting, which we set up in two flights with fourteen wines in the first flight and thirteen in the second. We had done a qualified guess on which wines should be the best, and put them in the last flight. Within each flight we randomly mixed the order to make the tasting semi-blind.
We have ranked the 1989 Vintage as a Very Good Vintage. The Vintage was not generally declared and many of the larger companies, including Symington’s, instead produced Single Quinta Vintage Ports.
The top wines for the group were Barros before Quinta da Cavadinha and Feist. Noticeable is perhaps that Dow’s Quinta do Bomfim was on half-bottles, something that probably affected the score in a negative way.
Tasting notes. Note that the points are for the actual bottle tasted. Read about how we set point on the page "How to understand our points valuations"
Sort on: Name Sten's rank Jörgen's rank Stefan's rank Group's rank
House | Aguila Companhia Uniao dos Vinhos do Porto e Madeira | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature, very beautiful but still very dark in colour. |
Bouquet | Cream candy, toffee, cherry, toasted aroma and some coffee in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Balanced port, easy to drink and like. Flavour of different toffees and torched sugar. Quite long and interesting finish. Drink and enjoy this port because it will not be better. |
SAI point | 15.90 | JB point | 15.90 | SS point | 16.25 | Group point | 15.69 |
SAI rank | 9 | JB rank | 14 | SS rank | 4 | Group rank | 10 |
Comment | |
House | Armada C. Da Silva | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Still rather dark but yellow mature colour. |
Bouquet | Mulberry, dark cherry blackberry and some liquorice in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Rather mature and maybe peaking even if some very soft tannin still exist. Liquorice, toffee and mulberry in taste. Balanced and quite elegant with a nice and rather long finish. Very easy to drink and enjoy today |
SAI point | 15.40 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 15.00 | Group point | 15.56 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 9 | SS rank | 22 | Group rank | 12 |
Comment | |
House | Barros | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Still dark in colour but with a yellow edge. |
Bouquet | Lovely nose of butterscotch, toffee, raisin and dark chocolate. |
Taste | Medium body. Quite mature and peaking but still with some elegant tannins and will be better. Quite dry but coffee, chocolate and butterscotch in taste. Balance and complex with a very elegant and attractive finish. Easy to drink and like. Just drink it and enjoy it! |
SAI point | 16.00 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 16.00 | Group point | 16.34 |
SAI rank | 6 | JB rank | 9 | SS rank | 7 | Group rank | 1 |
Comment | |
House | Burmester | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature, quite nice in colour. |
Bouquet | Minty, oak buy also volatile acidity in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking but the taste is destroyed of some unbalanced and volatile acidity and the finish seem to be rather short. |
SAI point | 10.00 | JB point | 12.90 | SS point | 8.00 | Group point | 12.28 |
SAI rank | 27 | JB rank | 26 | SS rank | 27 | Group rank | 25 |
Comment | This bottle was defect. |
House | Cabraco Companhia Uniao dos Vinhos do Porto e Madeira | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Quite beautiful, yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Fudge, mint, liquorice and some spiciness in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Will not be better. Quite sweet with mint, liquorice and spiciness in taste. Balanced and also elegant with an attractive and nice finish |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 15.90 | SS point | 15.25 | Group point | 15.63 |
SAI rank | 13 | JB rank | 14 | SS rank | 20 | Group rank | 11 |
Comment | |
House | Calem | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Very mature yellow in colour almost a hint of tawny. Very beautiful indeed. |
Bouquet | Sweetmeats, toffee, cacao, some chocolate and candy in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body Mature and peaking with toffee and crème caramel, candy and sweetmeats in taste. Quite sweet and elegant port. Easy to drink and enjoy with a quite nice finish. |
SAI point | 15.90 | JB point | 15.00 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 15.09 |
SAI rank | 10 | JB rank | 22 | SS rank | 15 | Group rank | 21 |
Comment | |
House | Calvares Companhia Uniao dos Vinhos do Porto e Madeira | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Still rather dark almost ruby with a yellow rim in colour. |
Bouquet | Fudge and dried fruit in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Balanced and quite elegant with fudge, toffee and maybe some chocolate in taste with an attractive finish. An astonishing good port. |
SAI point | 15.40 | JB point | 16.25 | SS point | 15.40 | Group point | 16.16 |
SAI rank | 17 | JB rank | 4 | SS rank | 19 | Group rank | 4 |
Comment | |
House | Champalimaud | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow, mature in colour but still rather dark. |
Bouquet | Lovely bouquet with crème caramel, chocolate, figs and some cacao in the nose. |
Taste | Medium bodied. Mature but still some tannins and will develop more and be better. Creme caramel, butterscotch and old grocery shop in taste. Very impressive port with an attractive finish. |
SAI point | 16.00 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 16.00 | Group point | 15.50 |
SAI rank | 6 | JB rank | 9 | SS rank | 7 | Group rank | 15 |
Comment | |
House | Cruz | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature, very beautiful in colour. |
Bouquet | Toffee, liquorice, fudge, burned candy and some crème caramel in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mostly toffee, burned candy and liquorice in flavour. Mature and peaking. Balanced and tasty but quite sweet. Interesting finish with lots of liquorice. Quite astonishing port! |
SAI point | 16.25 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 15.75 | Group point | 16.06 |
SAI rank | 4 | JB rank | 9 | SS rank | 12 | Group rank | 6 |
Comment | |
House | Dacosta Sogevinus | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Very bright amber in colour. |
Bouquet | Christmas raisin, figs, dried fruit and French plums in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Will not be better so drink and enjoy. Elegant and balanced. Raisin, figs and dried fruit in taste. Quite attractive and rather long finish. Easy port to appreciate. |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 15.25 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 15.53 |
SAI rank | 13 | JB rank | 21 | SS rank | 15 | Group rank | 13 |
Comment | |
House | Dom Joaquim Companhia Uniao dos Vinhos do Porto e Madeira | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour but still very dark. |
Bouquet | Dry fruit, dark berries but the bottle is corked. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature but still with some soft tannins. Dry fruit, dark berries and dark cherry in flavour but not quite drinkable when it is corked. Balanced but rather dry port but not enjoyable. |
SAI point | 13.00 | JB point | 13.50 | SS point | 10.00 | Group point | 12.22 |
SAI rank | 24 | JB rank | 24 | SS rank | 25 | Group rank | 26 |
Comment | This bottle was corked. |
House | Feist | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature but rather dark in colour. |
Bouquet | Lovely bouquet of toffee, figs, cream candy and fudge in the nose |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Balance and very elegant and tasty. Toffee, butterscotch, and fudge and much more in the mouth. Sweet but very complex port with a long, seductive and attractive finish. Very good for the vintage year! |
SAI point | 16.50 | JB point | 16.25 | SS point | 16.50 | Group point | 16.28 |
SAI rank | 2 | JB rank | 4 | SS rank | 2 | Group rank | 2 |
Comment | |
House | Kopke | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Fudge, some toffee, candy and violet in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Will not be better but balanced and very tasty. Toffee and candy in taste and the finish is quite seductive but maybe a little short but quite intensive indeed.. |
SAI point | 16.25 | JB point | 16.50 | SS point | 16.25 | Group point | 16.00 |
SAI rank | 4 | JB rank | 1 | SS rank | 4 | Group rank | 7 |
Comment | |
House | Magales Companhia Uniao dos Vinhos do Porto e Madeira | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Beautiful mature yellow in colour. |
Bouquet | Butterscotch, toffee and some spiciness in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and at its peak. Quite sweet. Easy to like and to drink with a nice finish. |
SAI point | 15.25 | JB point | 15.50 | SS point | 15.25 | Group point | 15.41 |
SAI rank | 19 | JB rank | 16 | SS rank | 20 | Group rank | 17 |
Comment | |
House | F. Martins | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Cacao and dark chocolate in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Will not be better but very easy to drink an enjoy today. Cacao in taste and with a nice finish. |
SAI point | 15.25 | JB point | 15.40 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 15.16 |
SAI rank | 19 | JB rank | 17 | SS rank | 15 | Group rank | 19 |
Comment | |
House | Maynard Barao de Vilar | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Still very dark, almost ruby in colour. |
Bouquet | Toffee, butterscotch and candy in taste. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Balanced and easy to drink. Will not be better. Toffee and butterscotch in taste. Rather intensive and attractive quite sweet finish. |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 16.25 | SS point | 15.90 | Group point | 15.78 |
SAI rank | 13 | JB rank | 4 | SS rank | 10 | Group rank | 9 |
Comment | |
House | Pedro Lopez Douro Wine Shippers and Growers Association | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Bright, yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Zest of orange and mature tropical fruit in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking but will not be better. Balanced and easy to drink and like with tropical fruit in taste. The finish is quite nice. Drink up! |
SAI point | 15.25 | JB point | 15.40 | SS point | 15.75 | Group point | 15.44 |
SAI rank | 19 | JB rank | 17 | SS rank | 12 | Group rank | 16 |
Comment | |
House | Prime Messias | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Some toffee cacao but also volatile acidity in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature but with quite a lot of volatile acidity and not enjoyable but the finish was not terrible. |
SAI point | 12.00 | JB point | 10.00 | SS point | 12.00 | Group point | 12.50 |
SAI rank | 25 | JB rank | 27 | SS rank | 24 | Group rank | 24 |
Comment | This bottle was defect. |
House | Quinta do Bomfim Dow | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Beautiful, very yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Candy, cacao, toffee and butterscotch in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature but still with some very attractive tannins and will maybe better? Balanced with candy, toffee and cacao in taste. The finish is quite nice, long and expressive. |
SAI point | 15.50 | JB point | 15.40 | SS point | 15.50 | Group point | 14.34 |
SAI rank | 13 | JB rank | 17 | SS rank | 15 | Group rank | 23 |
Comment | |
House | Quinta do Cachao Messias | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature colour. |
Bouquet | Pharmacy, burned sugar and butterscotch in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking with a little unbalanced acidity but quite drinkable. Burned sugar in taste and an acceptable, light finish Not quite convincing. |
SAI point | 15.00 | JB point | 16.00 | SS point | 15.00 |
SAI rank | 22 | JB rank | 9 | SS rank | 22 |
Comment | |
House | Quinta da Cavadinha Warre | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Menthol, coffee, cacao, dried fruit and old grocery shop in the nose. |
Taste | Quite full-bodied, sweet and elegant. Mature but with some very elegant and attractive tannins and will probably develop more. A balanced port, lovely to drink today. Coffee, cacao and old grocery shop dominate the taste and the finish is very long and attractive. |
SAI point | 16.75 | JB point | 16.40 | SS point | 16.75 | Group point | 16.28 |
SAI rank | 1 | JB rank | 2 | SS rank | 1 | Group rank | 2 |
Comment | |
House | Quinta do Estanho | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow, mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Sweetmeats, toffee butterscotch and some fudge in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking but with some very elegant tannins and will probably be better. Elegant and very tasty with toffee and butterscotch in the mouth. Lovely port and very easy to drink and enjoy with an intensive and long finish. |
SAI point | 16.50 | JB point | 16.40 | SS point | 16.40 | Group point | 16.16 |
SAI rank | 2 | JB rank | 2 | SS rank | 3 | Group rank | 4 |
Comment | |
House | Quinta do Fojo Churchill | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Still very dark almost ruby but with a yellow edge in colour. |
Bouquet | The nose is corked even if a hint of roasted coffee may be in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Quite mature but the taste is destroyed of the cork taste. The finish seem to be rather long but hard to judge. |
SAI point | 11.00 | JB point | 13.00 | SS point | 9.00 | Group point | 11.34 |
SAI rank | 26 | JB rank | 25 | SS rank | 26 | Group rank | 27 |
Comment | This bottle was defect. |
House | Quinta do Infantado | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Lovely yellow, mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Coffee, dried fruit, ginger and butterscotch in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking port but with some elegant tannins and will perhaps be a little better. Butterscotch and ginger in flavour. Elegant and with a nice but maybe short finish. |
SAI point | 16.00 | JB point | 16.25 | SS point | 16.25 | Group point | 15.13 |
SAI rank | 6 | JB rank | 4 | SS rank | 4 | Group rank | 20 |
Comment | |
House | Rocha Sogevinus | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Dried fruit, French plums, Christmas spiciness, and burned sugar in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Balanced but no fruit left. Dried fruit, French plums and spiciness in taste. Easy to drink. A modern vintage port with a quite attractive finish. |
SAI point | 15.00 | JB point | 15.40 | SS point | 16.00 | Group point | 14.91 |
SAI rank | 22 | JB rank | 17 | SS rank | 7 | Group rank | 22 |
Comment | |
House | Silva-Luz Douro Wine Shippers and Growers Association | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature in colour. |
Bouquet | Toffee, cacao, some spiciness and old grocery shop in the nose. Quite generous bouquet. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking but still with some elegant tannins. Flavour of toffee, some spiciness and old grocery shop. Balanced and elegant with a lovely and quite intensive finish. Very good indeed. |
SAI point | 16.00 | JB point | 15.00 | SS point | 15.75 | Group point | 15.22 |
SAI rank | 6 | JB rank | 22 | SS rank | 12 | Group rank | 18 |
Comment | |
House | Vasconcellos | Vintage | 1989 |
Colour | Yellow mature and very beautiful in colour. |
Bouquet | Elegant and attractive bouquet with spiciness and herbs especially basilica and thyme in the nose. |
Taste | Medium body. Mature and peaking. Balance and quite complex with thyme and basilica in taste. A lovely port to drink today. Drink up. We do not think it will be better. The finish is quite delicious and attractive but maybe a little short. |
SAI point | 15.75 | JB point | 16.25 | SS point | 15.90 | Group point | 15.53 |
SAI rank | 12 | JB rank | 4 | SS rank | 10 | Group rank | 13 |
Comment | |